Home National News Report: Archdiocese of Philadelphia investigates seminary harassment claims

Report: Archdiocese of Philadelphia investigates seminary harassment claims


PHILADELPHIA — The Philadelphia Inquirer daily newspaper reported Aug. 16 that the Archdiocese of Philadelphia is investigating allegations of sexual harassment from a former student at St. Charles Borromeo Seminary.

The paper reported that a letter with claims that a former student at St. Charles sexually harassed a freshman during the 2010-11 school year was sent to priests and deacons Aug. 14.

Archbishop Chaput
Archbishop Charles J. Chaput of the Archdiocese of Philadelphia, which has announced it is investigating cliams of improper behavior at its seminary. (CNS photo)

The claims are related to a blog post that also implicated a St. John’s Seminary in Boston, which the Archdiocese of Boston also is investigating.

Like the Boston case, the claims originated on social media, and is linked to a blog post that describes seminarians at “conservative seminary” drinking heavily, “cuddling” after a drunken party, and being involved in sexual behaviors and acts. The person who wrote the blog says he experienced sexual harassment at the Philadelphia seminary and later witnessed the other behavior in the Boston seminary.

The story says that the writer of the blog was 17 when the alleged abuse in Philadelphia occurred, which is described as “sexually inappropriate advances by a fellow student” in a dorm room.

The Inquirer reported that archdiocesan spokesman Ken Gavin said Aug. 16 that the seminary “recently became aware of allegations of sexual harassment by one seminarian of another that is purported to have occurred during the 2010-2011 academic year.”

“In keeping with the long-term policy of the seminary and the Archdiocese of Philadelphia,” he said, “this allegation was turned over the archdiocesan Office of Investigations for appropriate handling in light of policy and applicable law. As it is an active investigation, we are not able to comment upon it further.”

In his letter to archdiocesan clergy, Philadelphia Auxiliary Bishop Timothy C. Senior, rector of the seminary, said St. Charles has a longtime policy “against sexual violence, harassment and stalking.” It was last updated in 2015.

All seminarians are required to review the policy at orientation and to sign a form acknowledging they received it, Bishop Senior wrote.

He also noted that among the 170 seminarians about to begin the fall term at St. Charles, 50 will be new seminarians studying for the Philadelphia Archdiocese and other dioceses and religious orders of priests.

In separate announcement Sunday, two former priests who once served at parishes in the Archdiocese of Philadelphia have been found to be “not suitable for ministry,” the archdiocese announced Sunday night, after separate internal church investigations found that the clergy members had engaged in behavior that was either illegal or a violation of ministerial standards.

The archdiocese announced that the Rev. Andrew D. McCormick, a former priest who served stints at parishes in the Port Richmond section of the city and Bridgeport, Pa., among other locations, will be  removed of his right to function as a priest or will “enter into a supervised life of prayer and penance” after the church investigation found a “substantiated allegation” of sexual abuse of a minor. In addition, the archdiocese said Sunday, Monsignor Gregory J. Parlante was deemed to be no longer suitable for ministry after parish staff in Chadds Ford, Pa., last year found a package he was sent containing illegal drugs.